Back in March, I expressed my concerns about director Juan Solanas’ sci-fi romance film UPSIDE DOWN (2013). It didn’t help that reviews of it were less than positive. Therefore, I wasn’t in a rush to see it in the theater. When the film showed up on Netflix, however, I decided to give it a shot.
This post will include some spoilers so I can best
explain why it didn’t work for me.
The upside is that UPSIDE
DOWN is *definitely* a science fiction romance film. No doubt about it, when it
comes to SFR content, the film’s heart is in the right place. It's even got a great tagline: "What if love was stronger than gravity?"
The downside—and
it’s a big one—is that the film fails on multiple levels. I don’t even
know where to start, quite frankly.
I’ll tackle the setting
first. UPSIDE DOWN is certainly a pretty film to look at. Some might even
describe it as gorgeous. It’s a high concept idea with an easy-to-grasp premise:
two opposite worlds locked in an embrace by gravity. The “Up Above” world is
prosperous, while the “Down Below” world is dystopian in nature.
One of the problems,
however, is that in the beginning, the film sets a reader up to expect hard SF
elements. There’s a lengthy info-dump at the beginning (not unlike some hard SF
novels) and a clear attempt at presenting the science in a plausible way.
Unfortunately, the film veers off into science fantasy and is inconsistent
regarding the laws of physics.
One user review at IMDB
sums it up
perfectly: “Mass has no effect in some shots, but is critical to others.”



